If you look at the span of his bans, they are from months 04-11 of 2012. By BigBadHenz's ban, it should have been permanent. Within 7 months he has proven why he shouldn't be allowed. However, it's his first appeal I believe, and it has been about 6 more months, so I would give you a chance. My 2 cents for slightly being involved. It's up to Xeadin, however.